Metropolitan Water District of Southern California
about mwdnewsbusinessmember agenciesfinanceauditethicsjobscontactsearch
guidelines
Debriefing Procedures
Debriefing Procedures
  • Metropolitan notifies offerors when their submittals have been eliminated from competition.  The notice briefly provides the basis for the determination.

  • Offerors excluded from competition may request a debriefing.  The debriefing request shall be in writing and received by Contracting Services no later than 10 working days after notification by Contracting Services to the unsuccessful offeror.

  • If an offeror fails to submit a timely request, it may forfeit its right to a debriefing.

  • The debriefing by Metropolitan will occur as soon as practicable after receipt of the request.

  • The debriefing may be done orally, in writing, or by any method agreeable to Metropolitan and the offeror.

  • All meetings are attended by a representative from Contracting Services and the requestor or his or her designee.  In a case where a small business enterprise is being briefed, a representative from Metropolitan’s Business Outreach Program may also attend.

  • The debriefing includes:

    • Metropolitan’s evaluation of significant elements of the offeror’s submittal
    • A summary of the rationale for eliminating the offeror’s submittal
    • Responses to relevant questions about the solicitation process, applicable laws and regulations, and any reason that the submittal may have been considered non-responsive or the offeror not qualified.

  • The debriefing will not disclose:
      
    • The number of offerors
    • The identities of other offerors
    • The content of any other submittal
    • The ranking of offerors
    • The evaluation of other offerors
    • Names of evaluators associated with their scores

  • A record of the debriefing will be included in the contract file.

  • An offeror who has been debriefed may request additional post-award information.  This information will be provided if requested within 10 working days after award of the contract.  This additional information will include:

    • The overall ranking of all offerors
    • A summary review of the rationale for award, including an explanation of significant weaknesses and deficiencies in the offeror’s submittal
    • A review of other submittals excluding information that is confidential, proprietary, or secret.  No copyright, trade secret, or personal information be revealed.

  • A post-award debriefing will not disclose any information that ties a particular evaluator to particular ratings.

Nothing in this procedure shall preclude Business Outreach from having a more detailed post-award briefing with a small business enterprise.  Such a debriefing will exclude the release of copyright, trade secret, and personal information as well as the identity of evaluators associated with scoring.

Procurement Methods
Bid and Proposal Submittal and Results
Doing Business Contacts
Delivery, Payment Terms and Insurance Requirements
Debriefing Procedures
Protest Procedures and Appeals Board
Bid/Proposal Results
   

* All PDF documents on this site require Adobe Acrobat Reader 4.0 or higher. If you do not have Adobe Acrobat Reader, or must upgrade your version, you may download it for free from Adobe's Web site. If you are using a dial-up modem, please note that many of these documents are large in size and take a long time to open. Use of software other than Adobe Reader may cause discrepancies from the original documents. These risks will be assumed by the reader.

Page updated: July 19, 2007
August 1, 2007